New Review from Jeff York of Creative Screenwriting Magazine: “The Predator” Turns the Franchise into One Hot Mess

Creative Screenwriting Magazine

Is “The Predator” a sequel or a spoof? At time, it plays so comedically, it feels more like a parody of the original 1987 adventure “Predator.” Whatever the intent, “The Predator” is one hot mess. A summer-type actioner roaring into cineplexes after Labor Day, it’s loud, frenetic, and overstuffed with characters, exposition, and not one, but two predatory aliens this time. It’s fun in a sort of kitchen sink kind of way, but there’s too much plot, too many characters, and too many half-baked ideas for this one to be an effective thriller. It even feels like it was edited to minimize the damage with a running time well under two hours.

As in the original, another predator’s space ship has landed on earth and is up to no good in this one. The alien onboard ends up interfering with a military hit job on a drug cartel in Mexico and American soldier Quinn McKenna (Boyd Holbrook) is pissed about it. He steals the alien’sarmor after the interloper takes out his men and sends it to his autistic son Rory (Jacob Tremblay) in the States for safekeeping. Quinn steal a cloaking ball from the alien as well and swallows it to prevent the authorities from having it.

Creative Screenwriting Magazine

Keegan-Michael Key

His boy is autistic, but a genius tech wiz. Rory manages to decode the technical data found in the control panel of the alien helmet. The dreadlocked creature is here to harvest DNA from humans to enable his race to become a super one. That’s an interesting theme, obviously akin to theNazi’s but the film doesn’t seem to be interested in exploring any such political ramifications. Instead, this film cuts the chase literally and figuratively by having the alien and the government operatives chasing after Rory to get ahold of that data-rich helmet.

Two aliens are the villains, of course, but the other is a human one. Traeger is a “deep state” operative (Sterling K. Brown) and we know he’s bad from the get-go because he chews too many pieces of gum at one time. He’s a chomper too, the S.O.B., and we can’t have that. Meanwhile, Quinn escapes military prison after being blamed for the botched mission that ended with so many casualties, even though the government is well aware of the alien presence on earth. Conveniently, while being escorted away, the bigger of the two aliens shows up, a gunfight ensues, and Quinn escapes, along with the other military prisoners on his bush.

Soon, Quinn and the ragtag group of five military misfits he’s inherited (Trevante Rhodes,Thomas Jane, Keegan-Michael Key, Alfie Allen, and Augusto Aguilera) are going after the alien who’s going after Rory. Traeger and his minions are too, not to mention Olivia Munn as Casey Bracket, an evolutionary biologist who wanted to study the alien life form. That’s a lot of players in this mix, but the movie also squeezes in Yvonne Strahovski as Rory’s mom and Quinn’s ex, not to mention an adorable pit bull, a bunch of faceless local law enforcement types who’ll be easily killed by all, and a couple of alien hunting dogs belonging to the predator.

There’s way too much story this go-round, forcing characters to constantly stop and have to explain the plot to one another, as well as the audience, but the story is gibberish anyway. Director Shane Black, and his co-writer Fred Dekker, seem interested in blowing things up and slaughtering the cast of characters. It’s done with a sense of humor, of course, as is Black’s wont since he broke through as a writer penning the original “Lethal Weapon” movie back in 1987. Coincidentally, he broke through that same year as an actor in the original “Predator” film starring Arnold Schwarzenegger. His efforts here bring his breakout year together with a heady spin of glib humor and body-ripping violence.

Creative Screenwriting Magazine

Olivia Munn

The writer/director mined such veins to better results in 2013’s “Iron Man 3” and 2016’s “The Nice Guys. Here, he struggles to make it really funny or really tense. Worst of all, he develops a batch of ideas for the story that hang around for a few minutes and then disappear, never to be followed through on properly. The script sets up Nettles (Aguilera) as a lonely goof with a serious crush on Casey, but their relationship never really gels. Nor does Rory’s connection with that pit bull he encounters while on the run. In fact, the dog just is completely dropped from the story. Even main supporting players Baxley (Jane) and Coyle (Key) get the shaft by an under-developed script. They’re supposed to have a deep history, but their scenes together go by so quickly, with zippy, overlapping dialogue, that little of their bond registers. The film even blows the opportunity it sets up for McKenna to reunite with his ex as halfway through the film, Strahovski’s wife is written out of the story.

At least the young Tremblay gets some time to develop a character. He adds tics and quirks to hisportrayal, suggesting the troubled youth’s problematic condition. Meanwhile, everyone else struggles to make sense of their underwritten characters. Brown tries valiantly to play against type, chomping his gum loudly and cursing everyone, but the script doesn’t flesh out his villain enough. Jane is given, of all things, Tourette’s Syndrome to play for laughs. It may have been startling and outrageous when David E. Kelly made fun of it in “L.A. Law” back in 1990, butwe’ve come a long way and humor like that plays as insensitive and outdated today.

Black’s sensitivity is lacking even in the action scenes. They’re all rushed through, with frenetic editing, and very little time given to establishing context or spatial relationships. Every scene feels manic, every noise too loud and intrusive. Henry Jackman is usually a superb composer, but his pulsing take on Alan Silvestri’s original 1987 score never pauses to breathe. It’s as if Black was afraid to take his foot off the gas.

The film parrots and parodies famous lines and tropes from the original, but is Black having fun or casting aspersions? It’s hard to tell from the wildly veering tone. When a character yells, “Get to the choppers!” as he orders others to steal motorcycles, the film feels like affectionate homage. But when Black visually lampoons the dismembering death of Carl Weather’s original Dillon character, over and over again, it feels like he’s ridiculing the iconography.

Creative Screenwriting Magazine

Black even fails to make the most of the aliens. The original director John McTiernan ensured that the predator was scary as hell, but here, Black treats the vicious alien like more of a nuisance. The hunter never seems that formidable, even though he’s 10 feet tall in this one. There’s also no serious critique of the limits of machismo the way McTiernan essayed them in the first one. In the original “Predator”, Dutch’s men demonstrated inane hubris as they thought that they could out-muscle the monster in their midst. Only the Schwarzenegger characterrealized that strategy and cunning would be the weapons needed to take it down.

If only Black and Dekker tooled their story as such. Instead, they seem to be in love with everyone shooting at everyone else non-stop throughout the story. It makes for a lot of fireworks, but where are the cat and mouse elements that have distinguished the franchise throughout its three decades, even in the “Predator vs. Alien” pictures? This one seems content to just be silly entertainment, but why does it have to be so sloppy? The story even fails to conclude things properly, leaving loose ends regarding what happened to Traeger and Casey. Maybe we’re not meant to worry about such nagging questions, because let’s face it, the filmmakers didn’t.  

Catch the trailer of The Predator below:

Creative Screenwriting Magazine

from Film Reviews – Creative Screenwriting

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s